This Week in Crypto: Evaluating Ethereum ETFs and Crypto Projects

This Week in Crypto: Ethereum ETFs and Project Evaluations

This week has been significant in the U.S. crypto landscape, marked by the launch of exchange-traded funds (ETFs) for Ethereum. This development makes the second-largest cryptocurrency by market capitalization accessible to traditional investors. Have you ever thought about how to thoroughly evaluate crypto projects and what criteria to consider? In today’s edition, Matthew Burgoyne, a partner at the law firm Osler Hoskin & Harcourt LLP, offers a comprehensive guide for investment advisors on assessing crypto projects. Additionally, in our ‘Ask an Expert’ section, David Ben Kay, the president of Function X, provides valuable insights for advisors when evaluating potential investments.

As exclusive sponsors of this week’s Crypto for Advisors newsletter, we extend our congratulations to Grayscale on the successful launch of their new Ethereum ETF, simply branded as ETH. Clever branding indeed!

You’re reading Crypto for Advisors, CoinDesk’s weekly newsletter that unpacks digital assets for financial advisors. Subscribe here to receive it every Thursday.

How to Evaluate Crypto Projects: A Comprehensive Guide for Investment Advisors

As the crypto and blockchain sectors continue to gain traction, securities advisors face an increasing number of inquiries from clients regarding specific crypto assets and the underlying projects. Evaluating these projects necessitates a thorough understanding of several critical factors, ensuring informed investment choices. The sections below outline key areas for advisors to consider when assessing the legitimacy and potential of any crypto project and its corresponding asset:

Project Founder Due Diligence

• Investigate the backgrounds of project founders, focusing on their professional history, prior projects, and overall reputation within the industry.
• Seek verifiable expertise and remain vigilant for potential fraud indicators. Red flags may include newly created social media profiles and teams that operate anonymously.

Reviewing and Analyzing Tokenomics

Tokenomics encompasses the economic framework of the token, including its total supply, distribution methods, and utility within the project. Important aspects to examine include:

Evaluating the Business Plan

A robust and realistic business plan is fundamental to the sustainability of any token project. Typically, a business plan in the crypto realm is detailed in a white paper, a foundational document that articulates the project’s vision, the use of blockchain technology, and the strategy for implementation. Critical elements to assess include:

Identifying Risk Factors

• Recognizing potential risks is essential when evaluating token projects. Common risk factors include market volatility and technological challenges.

Regulatory Considerations

Assess whether the token’s issuance triggers regulatory obligations, such as compliance with anti-money laundering (AML) laws or securities regulations. Many new projects may fall under these categories, while established projects that have achieved significant decentralization may not. It is imperative to verify if project founders have sought legal counsel and whether their sales are restricted in key markets like the U.S. and the UK. Such restrictions may suggest efforts to bypass securities regulations, indicating that the token sale could involve the sale of securities or derivatives.

Conclusion

In summary, evaluating token projects requires a multifaceted approach, taking into account the credibility of the founders, the economic model of the token, the quality and viability of the business plan, potential risks, and adherence to regulatory standards. By meticulously analyzing these factors, investment advisors can offer their clients informed guidance, helping them navigate the complex and rapidly evolving crypto asset landscape.

– Matthew Burgoyne, Partner, Osler Hoskin & Harcourt LLP

Ask an Expert

Q: What are the key elements when evaluating crypto projects from a legal perspective?
A: From a legal standpoint, there are three primary areas I focus on when assessing a crypto project: compliance, governance, and security. It is crucial to determine whether the team consists of dedicated and competent individuals managing these aspects. While technical and marketing expertise is paramount, I also look for individuals with solid legal and financial backgrounds to ensure the company operates in accordance with local laws and is aware of international regulations that may impact its business plan. Ideally, these individuals should hold key leadership roles, but in early-stage companies, it’s acceptable for them to serve as advisors.

Q: How can advisors assist their clients in making investment decisions based on this information?
A: Legal compliance and governance are integral factors in any investor’s assessment of a project’s risks. While they are not the sole factors, they play a significant role in the overall evaluation. In the crypto sector, numerous legal issues remain ambiguous, presenting higher risks. Ultimately, it is up to the investor’s risk appetite and judgment to determine whether a project’s potential rewards justify the associated risks.

Q: Can you provide a good example of a project from a legal perspective?
A: Projects that have progressed beyond the startup phase and demonstrate a commitment to compliance and sound governance practices are generally more accessible for due diligence. Licenses, registrations, and required filings will likely be in place, along with established operational guidelines. This contrasts with early-stage startups, where more emphasis is placed on the individual team members and their past experiences, as well as the white paper outlining the regulatory environment in which the project intends to operate and how internal governance issues will be managed.

While these observations are broad and applicable to various projects, they hold particular significance in the crypto domain, where many legal matters remain fluid. Legal professionals are tasked with gathering objective information to equip prospective investors with comprehensive assessments, enabling informed decision-making.

– David Ben Kay, President, Function X

Keep Reading