Navigating the Controversy Around Ultra-Processed Foods and Food Classification Systems

The Controversy Surrounding Ultra-Processed Foods

While ultra-processed foods (UPFs) have gained significant attention in the food movement, there is a divide among advocates focused on promoting plant-rich diets. The NOVA classification system, used to categorize foods based on processing levels, often includes meat and dairy analogues in the UPF category, raising concerns among health advocates. However, the necessity of meat and dairy alternatives for reducing food emissions poses a challenge to this viewpoint.

Challenges with the NOVA Classification System

The NOVA system has been criticized for its sociopolitical categorization and its emphasis on processing levels rather than nutritional value. This has led to debates over the classification of plant-based alternatives as UPFs despite their favorable nutritional profiles compared to meat equivalents. The rigidity of the NOVA system presents obstacles in considering the broader impacts of food choices.

Redefining Approaches to Food System Transformation

To address the complexities of the food system, a shift in approach is necessary. Advocates for reduced processing levels must acknowledge the importance of certain UPFs, such as baby milk and meat substitutes, in driving dietary transitions. Updating the NOVA classification to reflect these nuances is essential for promoting a balanced perspective on food choices. Additionally, efforts should focus on promoting innovations that minimize processing while enhancing the nutritional quality of alternative proteins.

Ultimately, collaboration among various advocacy groups and a critical assessment of corporate influence in the food industry are crucial for advancing a sustainable, healthy, and just food system for the future.

Emily Armistead is Interim Executive Director at Madre Brava.
At Euronews, we believe all views matter. Contact us at view@euronews.com to send pitches or submissions and be part of the conversation.